On This Page
- How businesses and entities affect property settlements
- Identifying the legal and beneficial interests
- Business valuation
- Family trusts
- Companies and shareholdings
- Loans and related-party accounts
- Financial disclosure
- Third parties and competing interests
- Protecting the business during a dispute
- Structuring a practical settlement
- How I can help
- Frequently Asked Questions
- Discuss Your Business or Trust Matter
The end of a marriage or de facto relationship can create significant legal and financial issues when either party owns, controls or benefits from a business, company or trust. Establishing the true value of these interests—and determining how they should be treated in a property settlement—often requires careful examination of ownership, control, income, liabilities and historical transactions.
I advise business owners, directors, shareholders, trustees, beneficiaries and their former partners in complex family law property matters. I work with accountants, forensic experts, business valuers and tax advisers where appropriate to develop a clear understanding of the relevant structures and negotiate a practical, commercially informed outcome.
How businesses and entities affect property settlements
A company, business or trust cannot be assessed by looking only at the name recorded on its documents. The legal structure, practical control, financial benefits available to each party and rights held by third parties may all be relevant.
These matters commonly involve:
- Privately owned and family-operated businesses
- Companies with one or more shareholders
- Family trusts and discretionary trusts
- Unit trusts
- Partnerships and joint ventures
- Professional practices
- Corporate trustees
- Self-managed superannuation funds
- Shareholder and beneficiary interests
- Retained profits and accumulated reserves
- Director, shareholder and beneficiary loan accounts
- Division 7A loans
- Intellectual property and business goodwill
- Related-party transactions
- Business and trust assets located overseas
- Claims involving business partners, trustees or family members
The appropriate treatment of an entity depends on its governing documents, history, ownership, control and practical operation.
Identifying the legal and beneficial interests
The first step is to establish what each party legally owns and what financial interests or resources may be available to them. This can require examination of company constitutions, share registers, trust deeds, financial statements, tax returns, loan agreements, distributions and records of transactions with related parties.
A company is generally a separate legal entity, and trust property is not automatically the personal property of a trustee or beneficiary. However, the Court may examine the extent of a party’s ownership, control and ability to obtain benefits from a structure. Depending on the circumstances, an interest may be treated as property, a financial resource or an interest belonging to a genuine third party.
Business valuation
The accounting value shown in a balance sheet does not necessarily represent the market value of a business. A specialist valuation may need to consider earnings, assets, liabilities, cash flow, goodwill, market conditions, ownership restrictions and the extent to which the business depends on the personal efforts of one or both parties.
Valuation issues may include:
- Selecting an appropriate valuation methodology
- Distinguishing business goodwill from personal goodwill
- Identifying non-commercial or related-party expenses
- Assessing maintainable earnings
- Examining unusually high or low remuneration
- Accounting for debts and contingent liabilities
- Determining whether discounts for minority interests are appropriate
- Considering events after separation that affect value
- Avoiding double counting of business income and value
Where the parties cannot agree on value, an independent expert may be required. The expert’s instructions, source material and assumptions should be reviewed carefully.
For more information, see [Property and Business Valuation Disputes](/family-law/property-financial-matters/valuation-disputes/).
Family trusts
Family trusts can be particularly complex because legal ownership, control and financial benefit may be separated. A person may be a trustee, appointor, beneficiary, director of a corporate trustee or someone who exercises practical influence without holding a formal title.
Relevant considerations may include:
- Who established the trust and for what purpose
- Who is the trustee and appointor
- Who can appoint or remove the trustee
- The identity and rights of beneficiaries
- How distributions have historically been made
- Whether a party can influence distributions
- Whether trust assets originated from either party
- Whether independent beneficiaries have genuine interests
- Changes to the trust deed or control around separation
- Transactions between the trust and related companies or individuals
The existence of a family trust does not produce the same result in every case. Its treatment depends on the trust instrument, the evidence of control and the individual circumstances.
Companies and shareholdings
A company interest may range from a straightforward shareholding to a complex structure involving multiple companies, holding entities, trusts and related-party loans. The Court may need to consider the value of the shares, restrictions affecting their transfer, the company’s liabilities and the extent to which its assets can practically be accessed.
Orders affecting a company must also take account of the company’s separate legal identity and the rights of other shareholders, directors and creditors. A settlement should not be structured on the assumption that company property can simply be transferred as if it were personally owned by one of the parties.
Loans and related-party accounts
Business and family structures frequently contain loans between individuals, companies, trusts and relatives. It is important to determine whether an amount recorded as a loan represents a genuine enforceable liability, an asset, a distribution, an accounting entry or a contribution made without an expectation of repayment.
Evidence may include:
- Written loan agreements
- Repayment terms and security
- Interest charges
- Records of repayments
- Accounting and taxation treatment
- Communications between the parties
- The conduct of the alleged lender and borrower
- The financial circumstances in which the funds were advanced
Division 7A consequences may also arise where private-company payments, loans or benefits are provided to shareholders or their associates. Specialist taxation advice may be required before a settlement involving these accounts is finalised.
For more information, see [Tax Issues and Division 7A Loans](/family-law/property-financial-matters/tax-division-7a-loans/).
Financial disclosure
Parties to a family law property dispute have an ongoing duty to provide relevant financial information and documents. In a business or trust matter, disclosure may extend well beyond personal bank statements and tax returns.
Relevant records may include:
- Company and trust tax returns
- Financial statements and management accounts
- Business activity statements
- General ledgers and transaction reports
- Bank and credit-card statements
- Share registers and company searches
- Trust deeds and amendments
- Minutes and resolutions
- Loan accounts and loan agreements
- Payroll and remuneration records
- Distribution statements
- Contracts and invoices
- Business sale or restructuring documents
- Valuation and accounting reports
Failure to provide proper disclosure may delay the matter, increase costs and result in court orders or other sanctions.
Third parties and competing interests
Business structures often involve people who are not parties to the former relationship, including co-owners, business partners, trustees, adult children, parents and creditors. Their rights must be distinguished from the interests of the separating parties.
A third party may need to be joined to proceedings if the orders sought could directly affect their legal or financial interests. Conversely, joinder may be opposed where the proposed orders would not affect the third party’s rights or their participation is unnecessary.
For more information, see [Third Parties, Joinder and Section 106B Claims](/family-law/property-financial-matters/third-parties-joinder-section-106b/).
Protecting the business during a dispute
Preserving a functioning business can be important to both parties, particularly where it provides the family’s income or represents a substantial part of the property pool. Poorly planned litigation or settlement terms can disrupt employees, customers, suppliers and commercial relationships.
Interim arrangements may be needed to address:
- Access to financial information
- Payment of reasonable business expenses
- Drawings, salary and distributions
- Restrictions on disposing of assets
- Changes in company or trust control
- Incurring additional debts
- Preservation of business records
- Continued operation of the business
- Confidentiality of commercial information
If there is a genuine risk that assets or business value will be removed or diminished, urgent legal action may need to be considered.
Structuring a practical settlement
A property settlement does not necessarily require a business to be sold or divided. In many cases, one party retains the business or company interest while the other receives different assets or a balancing payment.
Possible outcomes may involve:
- Transfer of shares or units
- Resignation or appointment of officeholders
- Refinancing business or personal liabilities
- Payment by instalments
- Sale of the business or a particular asset
- Retention of the business by one party
- Security for deferred payments
- Releases from guarantees
- Tax-effective implementation, where legally available
- Orders or agreements governing transitional arrangements
The settlement must be assessed for practicality as well as headline value. Tax, liquidity, borrowing capacity, implementation costs and exposure under personal guarantees may materially affect whether an arrangement is workable.
How I can help
I assist clients with:
- Identifying business, company and trust interests
- Reviewing financial disclosure
- Analysing ownership and control
- Coordinating business valuations and forensic accounting
- Examining related-party transactions and loan accounts
- Identifying taxation issues requiring specialist advice
- Developing settlement proposals
- Representing clients in negotiation and mediation
- Seeking urgent protective orders
- Advising affected shareholders, trustees and third parties
- Preparing consent orders and implementation documents
- Representing clients in contested court proceedings
My objective is to develop a strategy that protects your legal position while recognising the commercial realities of the business and the importance of reaching an outcome that can be implemented effectively.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is a company’s property included in our family law property settlement?
A company is a separate legal entity, so its assets are not automatically treated as the personal property of its shareholders or directors. However, the value of a party’s shares, loans to or from the company, and the party’s practical control or financial benefit may be relevant. The Court may also have powers to make orders affecting a company in appropriate circumstances, subject to the company’s legal position and the rights of third parties.
Is a family trust protected from a property settlement?
Not necessarily. A trust is not automatically excluded merely because its assets are held by a trustee. Its treatment depends on the trust deed, the identity of the trustee and appointor, the history of distributions, the source of the trust assets and the degree of control or benefit available to either party. Depending on the circumstances, the trust may be treated as property, a financial resource or an interest genuinely belonging to third parties.
How is a privately owned business valued?
A specialist business valuer may consider the business’s maintainable earnings, assets, liabilities, cash flow, goodwill, industry conditions and ownership structure. The appropriate method depends on the type of business. The accounting value shown on a balance sheet does not necessarily represent its market value.
Will the business have to be sold?
Not necessarily. One party may retain the business while the other receives different property or a balancing payment. Whether this is possible depends on the business’s value, liquidity, available assets, borrowing capacity and the parties’ ability to implement the proposed settlement. A sale may be considered if neither party can retain the business fairly or practically.
Can my former partner claim part of a business I started before the relationship?
A business established before the relationship is not automatically excluded. Its initial value may be recognised as a contribution by the owner, but the Court may also consider changes in value and contributions made by both parties during and after the relationship. These may include direct work in the business, homemaking, parenting and indirect support that enabled the business owner to develop the enterprise.
What if only one of us worked in the business?
Working directly in the business is relevant, but it is not the only contribution considered. The other party may have contributed through homemaking, parenting, financial support or work performed without formal remuneration. The significance of each party’s contributions depends on the complete history and circumstances of the relationship.
Can business income be reduced to make the business appear less valuable?
Business results can be affected by remuneration, related-party expenses, discretionary spending, one-off costs and changes made around separation. A forensic accountant or valuer may examine the records and make appropriate adjustments when assessing maintainable earnings. Unexplained changes should be investigated through disclosure and expert analysis rather than accepted at face value.
What if my former partner controls all the business records?
Both parties have an ongoing duty to provide relevant financial information and documents. If records are not provided voluntarily, it may be possible to seek court orders for disclosure, issue subpoenas or obtain documents from accountants, banks, companies and other third parties. Urgent advice should be obtained if there is a risk that records will be altered, destroyed or removed.
Are shareholder or director loans treated as real debts?
That depends on the evidence. The Court may consider whether the loan is documented, whether interest is charged, whether repayments have been made and how it has been treated in the company’s accounts and tax returns. An accounting entry alone may not resolve whether the amount is genuinely repayable or how it should be treated in the settlement.
What is a Division 7A loan?
Division 7A is part of Australian taxation law and may treat certain payments, loans or benefits provided by a private company to a shareholder or associate as dividends. These rules can affect the tax consequences of a family law settlement involving company assets or loan accounts. Advice from a suitably qualified tax professional may be required before settlement terms are finalised.
Can a business partner, trustee or shareholder become involved in the proceedings?
Potentially. A third party may need to be joined if the orders sought could directly affect their legal or financial rights. Joinder is not automatic merely because a person is connected with the business or trust. The Court will consider whether the third party is necessary for the issues to be determined and whether their interests may be affected.
What happens if business assets are transferred after separation?
The transaction may need to be investigated, particularly if it was not conducted at market value or appears designed to reduce the property available for settlement. Depending on the circumstances, the Court may consider the transaction when determining the property settlement and may have power to restrain or set aside certain transactions, including under section 106B of the Family Law Act 1975.
How can the business continue operating while the dispute is resolved?
The parties may agree on interim arrangements concerning access to records, payment of expenses, salaries, distributions and significant business decisions. If agreement is not possible, interim court orders may be sought. Any arrangement should aim to preserve the value and operation of the business without unfairly prejudicing either party.
Can we resolve the matter without a final court hearing?
Yes. Once adequate disclosure has been provided and the relevant interests have been valued, many business and trust matters can be resolved through negotiation, mediation or arbitration. Any agreement should be documented in a legally effective form and reviewed for taxation, implementation and enforcement consequences.
What documents should I bring to the first consultation?
Useful documents may include recent company and trust tax returns, financial statements, trust deeds, company searches, shareholder records, loan agreements, business valuations and correspondence concerning ownership or control. You do not need to have every document before seeking advice; the initial consultation can identify the information required for the next stage.
Discuss Your Business or Trust Matter
Early advice can help identify disclosure problems, valuation issues and taxation risks before they become more difficult or expensive to address. If your property matter involves a business, company, trust or related-party financial structure, contact me to discuss the circumstances and your practical options.
This page provides general information only and does not constitute legal, accounting, financial or taxation advice. The treatment of a business, company or trust depends on its documents, operation and the individual circumstances of the parties.
